Proton Pass vs 1Password 2026: Which Vault Fits?

Choose Proton Pass if a free vault across devices and email aliases are priorities. Choose 1Password if your household wants shared vaults and simple family recovery, or your team values its developer toolkit. 1Password Individual starts at $2.99 per month for eligible new customers in the first year, billed annually; Proton offers a free plan.

The Proton Pass pricing page and 1Password personal pricing page were checked October 2026, on October 28. Proton displayed Pass Plus at $2.99/month billed $35.88 per year and Pass Family at $4.99/month billed $59.88 per year. Check current eligibility and renewal prices at checkout: both vendors display promotional offers.

Toolradar data: Our password manager ranking says Toolradar evaluated 37 password managers, checked October 28, 2026. The comparison below focuses on the controls two buyers are likely to use, rather than implying that every tool in the directory suits every household.

At a glance

Both provide mobile, browser and desktop access, so check support for the devices you use. The differences matter when a household shares credentials, a person needs recovery, or an organization must provision and remove employees.

Personal pricing and the renewal test

1Password's personal price page shows a first-year promotional rate for new customers buying directly with annual billing. The Individual offer totals $35.88 for the promotional year; the regular displayed rate is $3.99 per month, or $47.88 over 12 months. Families is $4.49 per month for the first year and $5.99 at the regular rate, equivalent to $53.88 and $71.88 respectively over a year.

These annual totals multiply the monthly equivalents by 12 and do not guarantee a future renewal rate. The promotion applies to new direct customers for the first year, according to 1Password, and is unavailable through third-party app stores. Verify renewal and regional terms at checkout.

Proton Free does not require a credit card and includes unlimited logins and devices, a password generator and passkey support. At the displayed offers, Pass Plus is billed $35.88 for 12 months and Pass Family $59.88 for 12 months. Proton presents both as discounted; verify who qualifies and the renewal amount at checkout rather than assuming the discounted rate continues. Our 1Password pricing breakdown covers other purchasing considerations.

Price verdict: Proton wins for someone who needs a permanent free plan. For a paid comparison, record the same billing term and renewal price for both products before deciding. A free plan is not automatically the cheapest choice if you need a paid sharing or recovery feature.

Passwords, passkeys and email aliases

Proton's free tier lists unlimited logins, notes and payment cards, plus support for passkeys across devices. It also includes 10 hide-my-email aliases. Pass Plus lists unlimited aliases, secure sharing, a built-in authenticator, dark-web monitoring and emergency access. Check which of those paid features are required by each person before comparing plans.

1Password's personal page lists password generation, autofill, use across devices and alerts for weak or compromised credentials. It also lists developer tools, including SSH workflows and Git commit signing. For a technical user who already relies on those workflows, the vault needs to fit both the browser and the development environment.

An email alias can help identify where unwanted mail originated and can be disabled without changing a primary mailbox. It does not replace a unique password or phishing-resistant authentication. Check how the service handles replies, custom domains and account recovery before moving important registrations.

Feature verdict: Proton's clearly stated free alias allowance is useful for privacy-conscious individuals. The right paid feature set depends on sharing and operational needs, not merely the number of passwords stored. Read the password manager guide for other approaches.

Sharing with family members

Proton lists Pass Family as a package for up to six users and says it contains the Pass Plus feature set for each user. 1Password Families includes five users in the base plan, lets members use private information while sharing through vaults, and gives the family organizer simple administrative controls. Five included members is not the same as a guarantee that every guest or additional user is free.

Separate shared and private credentials before inviting relatives: a streaming password might belong in a shared vault, while banking credentials belong in an individual vault. Review membership when someone leaves and rotate shared passwords they should no longer use. Removing a member cannot erase credentials they saved elsewhere.

Recovery also needs a plan. 1Password describes family organizer account recovery in its Families help documentation. Proton lists Emergency Access on Pass Plus. These are different mechanisms: read the setup instructions and test the recovery path with the person who will use it before relying on either during an emergency.

Family verdict: Proton includes one more person in its named family tier. 1Password publishes a clear family price and organizer recovery documentation. The right decision depends on the number of people, eligibility for the displayed offers, renewal terms and the recovery process each household accepts. Compare other options in our family password managers guide.

Encryption and the account recovery tradeoff

Proton says its end-to-end encryption covers fields including usernames and web addresses. 1Password also describes end-to-end encryption and says its protection uses an account password and a separate Secret Key. Read each vendor's design documentation against your requirements rather than infer identical implementations from the shared phrase.

Losing the credentials needed to open the vault is an operational risk. Keep recovery instructions accessible to an authorized person outside that vault. Businesses should document who approves recovery, how that person is authenticated and how access is logged; families should make sure the organizer knows which accounts can be recovered.

Neither encrypted vault removes the need to protect the email account and devices used to access it. Use unique passwords, enable a second factor where offered and keep devices updated. Our small-business 2FA setup guide outlines the next control to put in place.

Security verdict: Both vendors describe end-to-end encryption. 1Password's additional Secret Key and Proton's own account controls create different recovery requirements. Compare the procedures against your threat model instead of treating either marketing claim as a security audit.

Teams, SSO and provisioning

For organizations, compare business tiers rather than trying to run a shared personal account. Proton's business plan matrix lists an admin panel and account recovery on its business plans, with group management, activity logs, SSO and SCIM listed on Professional. The Professional page displayed $4.99 per user per month on annual billing, with a three-user minimum, on October 28; confirm the final invoice. Proton also publishes an integration guide describing SSO and SCIM, while a separate business-plan help page still calls SSO and group management forthcoming. Ask Proton to confirm availability for your provider and tenant before relying on either feature.

1Password's business pricing page showed a per-user Teams Starter price with a ten-user minimum, while its FAQ described a flat pack price. Ask for the exact bill before relying on either display. The page lists Business at $8.99 per user per month paid annually, with identity-provider integrations and expanded administration. For 10 users, Business comes to $1,078.80 a year at that rate, before taxes and other services.

Count the seats you will use before comparing a 10-member pack with a per-user product. Check SSO, provisioning, recovery and audit requirements: a starter pack may not satisfy a centralized identity policy.

Business verdict: Consider 1Password's Starter Pack for a ten-person team if its included features fit, after confirming the price. Evaluate Proton Professional when its listed SSO and provisioning controls are required, but obtain its current quote and test the integration before committing. A vendor's published feature list is not evidence that a connector meets your specific configuration.

Migration and offboarding checklist

First, inventory the accounts and decide which entries are business records. Both pages list password import, but format and coverage can vary: confirm how notes, passkeys, attachments and shared vault permissions move before exporting. Treat exported files as sensitive data, restrict access and remove the file securely after validating the migration.

Next, invite a pilot group to check browser logins, mobile apps and shared credentials. Establish which administrator can recover a locked user and remove access. Keep the old system available until the owner confirms the necessary data has moved.

Finally, rotate shared credentials a departing employee might know. Disabling a vault account limits future access, but does not invalidate a password copied elsewhere. The phishing prevention guide and authenticator app guide cover complementary controls.

For more context, see our 1Password review, Bitwarden review, 1Password vs Bitwarden and Bitwarden pricing. Toolradar also maintains entries for 1Password on Toolradar and Proton Pass on Toolradar.

How we compared

We read the vendors' personal and business plan pages and the 1Password Families help page on October 28, 2026. Prices are USD monthly equivalents where the vendor specifies annual billing; introductory and renewal rates are distinguished. We did not install, test or audit either product. Confirm current pricing and feature availability for your country and identity provider before purchase.

FAQ

Is Proton Pass free?

Yes. Proton describes a free tier with unlimited logins and devices and 10 hide-my-email aliases. Paid tiers add features including secure sharing and emergency access.

Is 1Password free?

1Password lists a 14-day trial for its personal plans. Its Individual and Families subscriptions have paid rates after that trial; verify current promotions before signing up.

Which supports more family members?

Proton advertises Pass Family for up to six users. 1Password Families includes five users in its base plan; check terms for additional members or guests.

Can both products store passkeys?

Both support passkeys. Proton lists them on its free plan; 1Password lists supported devices. Check import and export limitations before migrating.

Is the Proton paid plan cheaper?

The displayed annual Pass Plus offer and 1Password Individual promotion show the same monthly equivalent, but their eligibility and renewal terms need checking. Compare checkout totals for the same number of users and billing period.

Do teams need a business plan?

For centralized administration and employee access control, assess the vendors' business plans. Validate the exact SSO, provisioning and recovery features on the tier you intend to buy.

Cite this: Cyberpresso, "Proton Pass vs 1Password 2026: Which Vault Fits?", October 2026.

Some offers on this page may be paid placements or contain affiliate links.